2016 KryptonSite Awards: Pick The Best Guest Star Of Supergirl Season 1!

Ever since 2002, KryptonSite has hosted the annual “KryptonSite Awards,” which for years honored the best and worst of the TV series Smallville. Our last Smallville-related Awards happened in 2012 when we honored the entire series.

Now that a new Super-show has begun with Supergirl, we started to honor the best and worst of the Maid of Might’s first season, and then we got a bit… distracted. But we’re back, and we’re going to finish this whole process before Supergirl returns on October 10.

This is going to be the last category in this year’s Awards before we start adding everything together and revealing the results very soon.

The new category is Best Guest Star. You’ll notice that Dean Cain, Laura Vandervoort, and Helen Slater are not on the list… that’s because they were already up for Favorite Super Guest considering their roles in Kryptonian TV and movie history, so if you want to pick them, go there. If there is someone else that you feel is missing, though, please write in your choices below… there were a lot of great actors who guested on Supergirl last year and it’s difficult to narrow things down to a manageable list. (Also, write-ins are helpful because we had to submit this poll twice, and some of the choices dropped off, so it might be best to know so we can re-add them.)

Supergirl Season 1 is already available to purchase on Blu-ray – order yours today and support this website!


Craig Byrne

Craig Byrne has been writing about Superman TV since 1995, when the "Lois & Clark Krypton Club" launched. He founded KryptonSite.com in February 2001, becoming the first fan site for The WB/CW television series Smallville. He also wrote the Official Companion books for Smallville seasons 4-7 as well as the Smallville Visual Guide.

View Comments

  • I was totally going to vote for Barry until I saw that Jenna and Laura were also options under this category

  • Voted for Laura Benanti, she was great as Astra/Alura.
    I see the actors for young Kara and Cat Grant's son are included but not the actress that played young Alex. She was really great in the flashbacks, her name is Jordan Mazarati.

    • Jordan Mazarati was great, which is why there was a write-in section to make suggestions. I couldn't list every guest star that appeared in the history of the show, sadly.

Recent Posts

Superman Soars In New 2025 Movie Preview

DC Studios and Warner Bros. have released a new sneak peek for the new Superman…

1 day ago

Revealed: Possible Smallville Cameos in James Gunn’s Superman!

A leaked call sheet may have revealed Smallville stars' presence in James Gunn's new Superman…

4 days ago

Smallville Animated Update: It May Be A While…

On TalkVille, the reality of the current status of the Smallville animated project was discussed.

2 weeks ago

John Schneider Added To Salute to Smallville 2025 in Chicago!

John Schneider has been added to the 2025 Salute to Smallville convention in Chicago from…

2 months ago

Annette O’Toole’s Big Smallville Regret

Annette O'Toole discusses her biggest regret from her time on Smallville.

2 months ago

Two Guests Added for the Salute to Smallville 2025 Convention!

John Glover and Adrianne Palicki will be attending the 2025 Salute to Smallville convention.

2 months ago